Mill Street Brewery

• Canadian Brewery of the Year - 2009 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Canadian Brewery of the Year - 2008 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Best Microbrewery in the GTA (Greater Toronto Area) - 2008 Golden Tap Awards
• Canadian Brewery of the Year - 2007 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Best Microbrewery in the GTA - 2007 Golden Tap Awards
• Best Microbrewery in the GTA - 2006 Golden Tap Awards
• Best Microbrewery in the GTA - 2005 Golden Tap Awards
• Best Microbrewery in the GTA - 2004 Golden Tap Awards
• Critic's Choice: Best Microbrewery - 2003 Now Magazine

Tankhouse Ale

• People's Choice - North American Pale Ale - 2011 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Bronze - North American Style Pale Ale (Bitter) - 2009 Canadian Brewing Awards
• People's Choice - Pale Ale - 2009 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Speaker's Choice - Ontario's Craft Brewing Industry Tasting Event, 2009
• Gold - North America Style Pale Ale/Bitter - 2008 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Gold - Pale Ale - 2008 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Bronze - North American Style Amber / Red Ale - 2007 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Gold - Bitter & English Pale Ale - 2007 Canadian International Beer Championship, Barrie ON
• Gold - Pale Ale - 2007 Toronto Wine & Cheese Show
• Winner - 2007 Café Volo "IPA CHALLENGE
• Gold - Pale Ale - 2007 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Gold - Pale Ale - 2006 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Bronze - Pale Ale - 2007 Toronto Wine & Cheese Show
• Gold - Pale Ale - 2006 Toronto Wine & Cheese Show
• Gold Medal and Best of Class - British-style Pale Ale - 2005 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Silver - British-style Pale Ale - 2006 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Best of Show - C'est What? Annual Festival of Small Breweries
• Best Locally Produced Beer in the GTA - 2007 Golden Tap Awards
• Best Locally Produced Beer in the GTA - 2006 Golden Tap Awards
• Best Locally Produced Beer in the GTA - 2005 Golden Tap Awards
• Best Locally Produced Beer in the GTA - 2004 Golden Tap Awards
• Four Stars - 2006 Now Magazine

Coffee Porter

• Silver - Porter - 2011 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Gold – Porter - 2010 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Gold - Porter - 2010 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Bronze – Porter – 2009 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Gold - Porter - 2008 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Silver - Porter/Stout - 2008 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Bronze - Porter - 2007 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Silver - English Brown, Porter, and Stout - 2007 Canadian International Beer Championship, Barrie ON
• Gold - Porter/Stout - 2007 Toronto Wine & Cheese Show
• Silver - Porter/Stout - 2007 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Bronze - Porter - 2006 Toronto Wine & Cheese Show
• Gold - Porter - 2006 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Gold - Porter - 2005 Canadian Brewing Awards

Helles Bock

• Bronze - Traditional German Style – 2009 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Silver - Bock - 2009 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Gold - Bock Traditional German Style - 2008 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Bronze - Bock - 2005 Canadian Brewing Awards

Barley Wine

• Bronze – Barley Wine – 2010 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Gold – Strong – (2009 batch) 2010 Ontario Brewing Awards
• People’s Choice - Strong – (2009 batch) 2010 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Gold – Barley Wine – 2009 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Gold - Barley Wine - 2008 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Gold and Best of Class - Strong Ale - 2006 Canadian Brewing Awards

Original Organic Lager

• 2nd Place - “Favourite Beer” – 2009 New Brunswick Savour Food & Wine Show
• 2nd Place – Domestic Lager Category – 2009 Calgary Beer Fest
• Bronze - Light Lager Category - 2007 Ontario Brewing Awards

Stock Ale

• Gold - Cream Ale - 2009 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Gold - North American Style Blonde or Golden Ale - 2008 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Bronze - North American Style Blonde or Golden Ale - 2007 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Silver - Light Hybrid Beer, Dark Lager, Bock - 2007 Canadian International Beer Championship, Barrie ON
• Bronze - Cream Ale - 2007 Toronto Wine & Cheese Show

Belgian-Style Wit

• Silver - Belgian Style Wheat - 2011 Ontario Brewing Awards
• People’s Choice - Belgian Style Wheat - 2011 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Gold - Belgian Style Wheat (Witbier) - 2010 Ontario Brewing Awards
• People’s Choice - Belgian Style Wheat (Witbier) - 2010 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Silver - Wheat Beer - Belgian Style White/Wit – 2009 Canadian Brewing Awards
• “Best Beer” – Toronto Life Best of the City Edition – August 2009
• Gold - Wheat Beer - 2009 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Bronze - Belgian Style White (Wit) Beer - 2008 WORLD BEER CUP, San Diego**
• Gold - Wheat Beer - 2008 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Silver - Wheat Beer / Belgian Style "White" - 2007 Canadian Brewing Awards

Frambozen

• Bronze – Fruit or Vegetable Beer – 2010 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Gold - Fruit Beer - 2008 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Gold - Fruit or Vegetable Beer - 2007 Canadian Brewing Awards

IPA

• Silver - British India Pale Ale - 2011 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Bronze – English Style India Pale Ale – 2010 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Gold - Pale Ale - 2009 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Silver - Pale Ale - 2008 Ontario Brewing Awards

ESB

• Silver - British Pale Ale - 2011 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Gold - English Style Pale Ale (Bitter) – 2009 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Silver - Bitter - 2009 Ontario Brewing Awards
• Silver - English Style Pale Ale Bitter - 2008 Canadian Brewing Awards

Scotch Ale

• Silver - Scotch Ale - 2008 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Silver - Dark Ale - 2008 Ontario Brewing Awards

Pilsner

• Silver - European Style Lager (Pilsner) - 2010 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Silver - European Style Lager (Pilsner) - 2009 Canadian Brewing Awards
• Gold - European Style Lager (Pilsner) - 2008 Canadian Brewing Awards
• People's Choice Award - Pilsner - 2008 Ontario Brewing Awards

Cobblestone Stout

• Bronze - Stout - 2008 Canadian Brewing Awards

Belgian Tripel

• Gold - Specialty - 2009 Ontario Brewing Awards

Lemon Tea Beer

• Gold - Flavoured Beer - 2011 Ontario Brewing Awards
• People’s Choice - Flavoured Beer - 2011 Ontario Brewing Awards

Franconian Bock

• Gold - Bock - 2011 Ontario Brewing Awards

Spring Bock

• Gold - Bock - 2010 Ontario Brewing Awards